Institute for
Healthy Families

You do not have to choose between your convictions and your child.

7 minute read

A great many of the families we work with are not trying to resolve a disagreement. They are trying to survive one without losing each other, which is a different problem and a more workable one.

This is the question underneath most of the calls we take: is it possible to hold a conviction and hold a relationship at the same time? In our experience it is, but it takes deliberate work and it is not the same as pretending the disagreement is not there.

Is it possible to disagree and stay close?

Yes, and most families already do it somewhere else in their lives without noticing. What makes disagreement about identity or faith feel different is that one side sees it as being about whether they are accepted rather than a conflict about values.

The work is separating those two things. A household where people can say "I view this differently, but I see you, and I love you, and I am not going anywhere" is doing something most families never learn to do, and it is learnable.

What does that look like day to day?

Concretely: not reopening the disagreement at every opportunity, being specific about what you do and do not require in your own home, and continuing to do ordinary things together that have nothing to do with the disagreement.

The ordinary things carry more weight than parents expect. A relationship that only exists at the site of the conflict will eventually be indistinguishable from the conflict.

Where should the boundaries sit?

Boundaries work when they are about your own behavior and your own home rather than about controlling another. "This is what happens in this house" is reasonable. "You must think differently" is not.

Boundaries also need to be stated calmly, in advance, and applied consistently. A boundary announced in the middle of an argument feels like punishment, and it will be treated as such.

What if the disagreement is about faith itself?

This is one of the most common issues we are asked to help with, and it is one of the reasons families come to a practice that is open about its own frame of reference rather than neutral about it.

Our aim in that room is not to win the disagreement on a parent's behalf. It is to help a family stay in relationship while the disagreement is unresolved, which is usually what everyone in the home actually wants and nobody knows how to achieve.

Questions parents also ask

No. It means the relationship is not conditional on agreement. Those are different things, and most of the work we do with parents is about learning to hold the second one without conceding the first. We believe love has room for disagreement.

If this is your situation

You can talk it through with someone before deciding anything.

A first conversation is not a commitment. It’s a time for us to understand your story and for you to hear our approach. We will tell you honestly whether we are the right people to help.

Speak with someone